← Heraldware
AsanavsSmartsheet

TL;DR

Asana is a task and project manager with a free tier for one or two people, then paid seats at $10.99 and $24.99 a month billed annually. Smartsheet is a spreadsheet that grew into a work platform: $9 and $19 a member a month billed yearly, with unlimited free contributors and guests on the paid tiers. Choose Asana for how work feels day to day; choose Smartsheet when the data model, automations and portfolio reporting matter more than the interface.

Smartsheet is priced per member with a spreadsheet underneath. Pro is $12 per member a month billed monthly or $9 billed yearly, for 1 to 10 members with unlimited free Contributors, and includes unlimited sheets, forms and reports, Gantt, table, board and calendar views, rich formulas, conversational AI features and 250 automations a month. Business is $24 monthly or $19 yearly for 3 or more members, adding unlimited Guests and Contributors, timeline view, workload tracking, admin capabilities, unlimited automations, connections to external AI tools and 1 TB of attachment storage. Enterprise is custom for 10 or more members and brings scenario planning, portfolios, SAML-based single sign-on, an Enterprise Plan Manager and unlimited attachment storage. Advanced Work Management sits above that with Control Center, Dynamic View, Data Shuttle, Connectors and premium support, and add-ons such as Dynamic View start at $125 a month and Data Shuttle at $100 a month.

The cost arithmetic rewards different team shapes. A team of five pays Asana $54.95 a month annually on Starter or $124.95 on Advanced; the same five on Smartsheet pay $45 a month on Pro or $95 on Business, and stakeholders who only need to read can be added as free Contributors on Pro or free Guests on Business rather than as seats. What Asana offers in exchange is a purpose-built task experience - assignees, dependencies, portfolios of projects and a reporting layer designed around them - while Smartsheet offers a data model you can formula, import and export, plus the automation volume that comes with unlimited automations on Business.

Pros & cons

👍 Asana Pros

  • Free Personal plan for one or two users with unlimited tasks and projects
  • Starter at $10.99 per user a month billed annually includes timeline, Gantt and dashboards
  • AI features included on paid plans, with 50,000 AI Studio credits per account a month
  • View-only licences and guest controls keep stakeholders off the paid seat count
  • Enterprise+ adds SIEM integration, data residency and audit logs

👎 Asana Cons

  • Advanced doubles the per-seat cost to $24.99 a month billed annually
  • The free tier is limited to one or two people, so a team pays immediately
  • Monthly billing raises Starter to $13.49 and Advanced to $30.49
  • Data lives in Asana's model rather than in rows you can formula and export freely

👍 Smartsheet Pros

  • Pro at $9 per member a month billed yearly, for up to 10 members with unlimited free Contributors
  • Business at $19 yearly adds unlimited Guests, workload tracking and unlimited automations
  • Spreadsheet foundations: formulas, imports, and Gantt, table, board and calendar views
  • 1 TB of attachment storage on Business; unlimited on Enterprise
  • Enterprise adds SAML-based SSO, portfolios and scenario planning

👎 Smartsheet Cons

  • Business needs at least 3 members, and Enterprise needs 10 or more
  • Pro caps automations at 250 a month and members at 10
  • Useful features such as Dynamic View and Data Shuttle are priced from $125 and $100 a month as add-ons
  • The interface is a grid first, which is a poor fit for teams that think in boards and timelines

Side by side

FeatureAsanaSmartsheet
Free tierPersonal for 1-2 users, unlimited tasks and projectsNo free tier; free trial available
Entry paid planStarter at $10.99 per user/month billed annuallyPro at $9 per member/month billed yearly, up to 10 members
Mid planAdvanced at $24.99 per user/month annuallyBusiness at $19 per member/month yearly, 3+ members
Monthly billingStarter $13.49, Advanced $30.49Pro $12, Business $24 per member
Guests and observersView-only licences and guest invitation controlsUnlimited free Contributors on Pro, unlimited Guests on Business
AutomationsIncluded in the plan tiers250 a month on Pro, unlimited on Business
StorageUnlimited tasks and projects on all tiers1 TB attachments on Business, unlimited on Enterprise
Security tierEnterprise+ adds SIEM, data residency, audit logsEnterprise adds SAML-based SSO, portfolios, scenario planning
Add-onsAI Studio usage beyond included creditsDynamic View from $125/month, Data Shuttle from $100/month

Verdict

Pick Asana if

Pick Asana if the team lives in the tool every day

Asana is the better choice when the people doing the work want a task-first interface with dependencies, dashboards and a portfolio view that non-technical stakeholders can read. The free Personal tier makes it easy to start, and the included AI features on Starter reduce the need to buy a separate assistant. Budget for Advanced once you need the deeper governance, and remember the free tier stops at two people.

Pick Smartsheet if

Pick Smartsheet if the data model comes first

Smartsheet wins when your projects are really tables that need formulas, bulk imports, rollups and automations, and when the people who need visibility should not cost a seat. At $9 and $19 per member a month billed yearly it undercuts Asana's equivalent tiers, and unlimited automations on Business is a genuine differentiator. Just check the add-on prices before you commit: Dynamic View and Data Shuttle start at $125 and $100 a month.

What the vendors say, and what we did not measure

No user reviews or ratings were gathered for this comparison. Every price and feature is from asana.com/pricing and smartsheet.com/pricing as the vendors publish them.

Who Should Use Which?

Use Asana if you...

  • Marketing, product and operations teams that want tasks, timelines and dashboards rather than grids
  • Two people starting free and upgrading only when the team grows
  • Organisations that need view-only licences for executives and clients
  • Companies that want audit logs, data residency and SIEM integration through Enterprise+

Use Smartsheet if you...

  • Project and portfolio management where every cell needs a formula or a rollup
  • Teams with many read-only stakeholders who would otherwise be paid seats
  • Processes that need more than 250 automations a month
  • Organisations standardising on SAML SSO and scenario planning across a portfolio

FAQ

Is Smartsheet cheaper than Asana?

Per seat, yes on the published tiers. Smartsheet Pro is $9 per member a month billed yearly and Business is $19, against Asana Starter at $10.99 and Advanced at $24.99. Smartsheet also charges nothing for unlimited free Contributors on Pro and unlimited Guests on Business, while Asana's equivalent access comes through view-only licences and guest permissions.

Do either of them have a free plan?

Asana does: Personal is free forever for one or two people with unlimited tasks and projects. Smartsheet's pricing page lists no free tier, only a trial, so a team that needs to stay at zero cost should start in Asana.

Which is better for portfolio reporting?

Smartsheet puts portfolios, scenario planning and an Enterprise Plan Manager on its Enterprise tier, alongside dashboards built on grid data. Asana reports across projects with dashboards from Starter upwards, and adds portfolios and goals on the higher tiers. If your portfolio is a spreadsheet with rollups, Smartsheet is the natural fit.

How do their AI features compare on price?

Asana includes AI Teammates and Asana Dash in its paid plans, with 5 requests per user a month up to 50 per account and 50,000 AI Studio credits per billing account a month. Smartsheet includes conversational AI features in Pro and lets Business and Enterprise connect to external AI tools, with Control Center and premium support reserved for the Advanced Work Management tier.

Can I import between them?

In both directions, with caveats. Smartsheet imports and exports CSV and Excel natively, and its Data Shuttle product automates that for $100 a month or more. Asana supports CSV import of tasks and has a public API; structure such as dependencies, custom fields and formulas has to be rebuilt rather than lifted.

Spot an outdated price or feature? Let us know and we'll verify it.

Heraldware analysis engine

reviewed · data sourced from official product pages · sources: asana.com, smartsheet.com