← Heraldware
BeehiivvsMailchimp

TL;DR

Beehiiv is built around newsletters and monetization: Free holds up to 2,500 subscribers with unlimited sends, Lite is $49 a month yearly, Pro is $95, and Enterprise is a quote. Mailchimp is a general email platform: Free exists for small lists, and the paid tiers it shows run $13, $20 and $350 a month for the first 12 months at the selected contact level, with pricing stepping up after. Beehiiv gives away more at the free tier and charges for monetization tooling; Mailchimp has the lower entry price and a wider marketing feature set.

Mailchimp is a broader marketing platform with a smaller free entry. Its pricing page shows promotional rates for the first 12 months at whatever contact level you select: $13 a month for Essentials, $20 for Standard and $350 for Premium in the displayed tier, each with a note that pricing applies for 12 months. Above 10,000 contacts the page advertises a 15% saving on the first year. The platform spans email campaigns, SMS, automations, landing pages, forms and a built-in CRM, with a 14-day free trial on paid tiers.

The core trade is where each one spends your money. Beehiiv spends it on the newsletter as a product: the free tier is unusually generous, and the paid tiers exist to monetize the list through subscriptions, ads and recommendations. Mailchimp spends it on breadth: lower entry pricing and a marketing stack that covers email, SMS and CRM, but with contact-based pricing that climbs as the list grows and promotional rates that step up after year one.

Pros & cons

👍 Beehiiv Pros

  • Free plan holds up to 2,500 subscribers with unlimited email sends
  • Lite at $49 a month yearly adds paid subscriptions at a 0% take rate
  • Ad monetization, listed as averaging $39 a month, sits inside the same dashboard
  • Pro at $95 a month removes branding and adds advanced analytics and webhooks
  • Recommendation network and audience polls support list growth natively

👎 Beehiiv Cons

  • The paid tiers are priced well above Mailchimp's entry rate
  • Ad revenue is a published average rather than a guaranteed return
  • The $49 and $95 figures assume yearly billing
  • It is newsletter-shaped, so broader marketing campaigns are not the focus
  • Enterprise pricing is handled by contact rather than published

👍 Mailchimp Pros

  • Entry pricing undercuts Beehiiv at $13 a month for Essentials in the displayed tier
  • Covers email, SMS, automations, landing pages, forms and a CRM in one platform
  • 14-day free trial on paid tiers
  • 15% saving advertised on the first year above 10,000 contacts
  • Long track record and a large template and integration library

👎 Mailchimp Cons

  • Advertised rates apply for 12 months and step up afterward
  • Pricing is tied to contact count, so cost rises with list size
  • The premium tier at $350 a month is a large jump from the entry tiers
  • The free plan is far smaller than Beehiiv's 2,500-subscriber tier
  • Newsletter monetization features such as paid subscriptions are not the core offering

Side by side

FeatureBeehiivMailchimp
Free tierUp to 2,500 subscribers with unlimited sendsFree plan for small lists; paid tiers with a 14-day trial
Entry paid planLite $49 a month yearlyEssentials $13 a month for 12 months in the displayed tier
Mid tierPro $95 a month yearlyStandard $20 a month for 12 months in the displayed tier
Top tierEnterprise, priced by contactPremium $350 a month for 12 months in the displayed tier
Pricing basisBy subscriber tier with a published free ceilingBy contact count with promotional first-year rates
MonetizationPaid subscriptions at 0% take rate, ad network, recommendationsNot the core offering; sells marketing tooling instead
ChannelsEmail and newsletter toolingEmail, SMS, automations, landing pages, forms, CRM
AI toolingbeehiiv MCP on paid tiersAI-assisted content and campaign tools
Rate stabilityPublished list prices on the pricing pagePromotional rates that step up after 12 months
Best fitCreators monetizing a newsletterBusinesses running a wider marketing stack

Verdict

Pick Beehiiv if

Choose Beehiiv if the newsletter is the business

Beehiiv suits creators who intend to earn from the list itself. Paid subscriptions with no platform cut, an ad network and a recommendation network are the reason to pay $49 rather than a smaller sum, and they only matter if you run a publication. The free tier holding 2,500 subscribers with unlimited sends also means the cost does not arrive until the list is already working.

Pick Mailchimp if

Choose Mailchimp if email is one channel

Mailchimp suits businesses that send campaigns, run automations, reach contacts over SMS and want a CRM under one bill. The entry price is lower, and the feature set is wider than a newsletter platform's. The trade-offs are contact-based pricing and promotional rates that step up after the first year, which rewards knowing your list trajectory before committing.

What the vendors say, and what we did not measure

Who Should Use Which?

Use Beehiiv if you...

  • you publish a newsletter and want to charge for subscriptions
  • you want an ad network and recommendation network inside the same dashboard
  • you prefer a generous free tier that scales with the list
  • you want published list prices rather than contact-based quotes

Use Mailchimp if you...

  • you run campaigns across email and SMS rather than one publication
  • you want automations, landing pages, forms and a CRM together
  • you need a lower entry price for a small list
  • you already have integrations built against its ecosystem

FAQ

Which is cheaper for a small list?

Mailchimp's entry tier is advertised at $13 a month for 12 months in the displayed contact level, against Beehiiv's Lite at $49 a month yearly. Beehiiv's free plan is far more generous though, holding up to 2,500 subscribers with unlimited sends.

Can Beehiiv handle marketing automation?

It offers automations on paid tiers, but it is built around the newsletter. For multi-channel campaigns, SMS and a CRM, Mailchimp's platform is the wider tool.

Why does Mailchimp show prices for 12 months?

The rates on its pricing page are promotional for the first year, after which pricing steps up. Beehiiv lists standard rates without that structure.

Does Beehiiv take a cut of subscription revenue?

No. Paid subscriptions on Beehiiv carry a 0% take rate, so the platform does not take a percentage of what readers pay you.

Which is better for growing a list?

Beehiiv includes a recommendation network and audience polls designed for newsletter growth. Mailchimp focuses on campaign performance and channel reach rather than publication growth loops.

Do either charge based on contact count?

Mailchimp does, which is why its cost rises with list size. Beehiiv prices by subscriber tier with a published free ceiling, giving more predictable cost as the list grows.

Spot an outdated price or feature? Let us know and we'll verify it.

Heraldware analysis engine

reviewed · data sourced from official product pages · sources: beehiiv.com, mailchimp.com