← Heraldware
NordVPNvsProton VPN

TL;DR

NordVPN sells long terms at aggressive intro rates: Basic is EUR 3.89 a month billed as EUR 93.36 for 24 months and renews at EUR 139.08 a year, Complete is EUR 4.89 a month and renews at EUR 219.48 a year. Proton VPN sells a simpler two-product ladder: VPN Plus at $3.49 a month on a two-year term ($83.76 for the first 24 months, then $83.88 a year) and a genuinely usable free tier at one device and ten countries. The real differences are the free plan, the ecosystem around the VPN, and how each treats renewal.

Proton VPN keeps its ladder to three options and prices in dollars. The free plan is $0 with one device at a time, medium speed and servers in ten countries, chosen randomly. VPN Plus is $9.99 a month month-to-month, or $3.49 a month on the two-year plan, billed as $83.76 for the first 24 months and then renewing at $83.88 every 12 months; it covers ten devices at once, the full server estate of 20,000+ servers in 140+ countries, streaming, P2P, an ad, tracker and malware blocker and priority support. Proton Unlimited is $7.99 a month on the two-year term, $191.76 for the first 24 months then $119.88 a year, and folds the VPN into the wider Proton suite: Mail, Pass, Drive and Calendar. Proton states a 30-day money-back guarantee on paid plans.

Two things separate them beyond the price list. First, the free tier: Proton's is a real product with one device and ten countries and no time limit, while NordVPN's answer is a trial of the paid service. Second, ecosystem: NordVPN's upper tiers bundle a password manager, breach monitoring, antivirus-backed protection and storage, which makes Complete a security bundle rather than a VPN; Proton's upper tier bundles encrypted mail, passwords, storage and calendar instead, and the company's positioning leans on Swiss jurisdiction, open-source clients and published no-logs audits.

Pros & cons

👍 NordVPN Pros

  • Two-year intro of EUR 3.89 a month for Basic, billed EUR 93.36 up front
  • Complete at EUR 4.89 a month bundles breach monitoring, password manager and 1 TB storage
  • One-year terms published as well, so a shorter commitment is possible
  • 30-day money-back guarantee on every plan
  • Large server estate backed by Nord Security's network

👎 NordVPN Cons

  • Renewal is annual and materially higher: EUR 139.08, EUR 219.48 and EUR 338.28 by tier
  • The best rate requires 24 months paid in advance
  • No permanently free tier; the free option is a trial of paid plans
  • Ultimate Max extras such as cyber insurance carry their own terms and limits

👍 Proton VPN Pros

  • A permanently free plan: one device, ten countries, medium speed, no time limit
  • VPN Plus at $3.49 a month on two years, billed $83.76 for the first 24 months
  • Ten devices simultaneously on VPN Plus, 20,000+ servers in 140+ countries
  • Swiss-based, open-source clients, published no-logs audits
  • Proton Unlimited at $7.99 a month adds Mail, Pass, Drive and Calendar

👎 Proton VPN Cons

  • Free tier is limited to one device and ten countries with medium speeds
  • The two-year rate is a first-term price, then $83.88 a year
  • Month-to-month VPN Plus is $9.99, three times the two-year rate
  • The bundle only pays off if you actually use the wider Proton products

Side by side

FeatureNordVPNProton VPN
Free optionTrial of paid plans; no permanent free VPN tierFree plan: 1 device, 10 countries, medium speed
Entry paid planBasic, EUR 3.89 a month on 2 years (EUR 93.36), renews EUR 139.08 a yearVPN Plus, $3.49 a month on 2 years ($83.76), renews $83.88 a year
Mid tierComplete, EUR 4.89 a month on 2 years (EUR 117.36), renews EUR 219.48 a yearProton Unlimited, $7.99 a month on 2 years ($191.76), renews $119.88 a year
Top tierUltimate Max, EUR 8.89 a month on 2 years (EUR 213.36), renews EUR 338.28 a yearProton Unlimited covers the top of the consumer ladder
Month-to-monthPublished on the 1-month term; the highest rate on the pageVPN Plus at $9.99 a month
DevicesVaries by plan and device type; confirm on the tier you buyTen devices on VPN Plus, one on the free plan
Bundle at the topAntivirus-backed protection, breach monitoring, password manager, 1 TB storage, dedicated IP, cyber insuranceEncrypted mail, password manager, storage, calendar and docs
OperatorNord SecurityProton, Swiss-based per its own site
Money back30-day money-back guarantee30-day money-back guarantee on paid plans

Verdict

Pick NordVPN if

You want a security bundle around the VPN

Choose NordVPN if you want the lowest two-year entry rate and are happy to have breach monitoring, a password manager and storage arrive with the plan. Complete at EUR 4.89 a month for the first two years is the tier that does the most work, and the one-year terms give you a shorter commitment at EUR 5.49 and EUR 6.49 a month. Just price the renewal: EUR 219.48 a year is what Complete costs after the intro.

Pick Proton VPN if

You want a VPN you can test for free and keep simple

Choose Proton VPN if you want to run the product before paying, or if privacy posture and jurisdiction matter more than bundled extras. The free plan at one device and ten countries is usable, and VPN Plus at $3.49 a month on two years covers ten devices with the full server estate. If you already pay for mail and storage elsewhere, Proton Unlimited at $7.99 a month can replace several subscriptions.

What the vendors say, and what we did not measure

We did not collect an independent review corpus for this pair, so nothing above is user sentiment. Every price comes from the vendors' own pricing pages fetched on the date shown: NordVPN served euro prices for an EU checkout and Proton served US dollars.

Who Should Use Which?

Use NordVPN if you...

  • You want one subscription to cover VPN, passwords and breach alerts
  • You are happy to commit two years to reach the lowest rate
  • You need a dedicated IP or antivirus-backed web protection
  • You prefer a single vendor for the household's security tools

Use Proton VPN if you...

  • You want to try a VPN thoroughly before paying
  • Privacy, open-source clients and jurisdiction are the deciding factors
  • You would use encrypted mail, password manager and storage together
  • One device at a time is enough for your free-tier use

FAQ

Which is cheaper on the two-year rate?

Proton VPN, marginally, in the currencies quoted here: VPN Plus at $3.49 a month billed $83.76 for 24 months against NordVPN Basic at EUR 3.89 a month billed EUR 93.36. The two are close enough that currency and renewal terms matter more than the headline.

What do these cost after the first term?

NordVPN's page lists renewals of EUR 139.08 a year for Basic, EUR 219.48 for Complete and EUR 338.28 for Ultimate Max. Proton VPN Plus renews at $83.88 every 12 months and Proton Unlimited at $119.88 a year. Both are step-ups from the intro rate, and both should be in your budget from year three.

Does NordVPN have a free plan?

No permanent free VPN tier is listed on its pricing page; the free route is a trial of the paid plans. Proton VPN runs a permanent free plan with one device, ten countries and medium speeds, which is the clearest structural difference between the two.

How many devices can I connect?

Proton VPN Plus allows ten devices at once, and the free plan allows one. NordVPN allows a device count that varies by plan and device type, so check the specific tier you are buying; its upper plans also add a dedicated IP option.

What do the top tiers actually add?

NordVPN's Ultimate Max adds a dedicated IP and cyber insurance of up to EUR 5,000 for scams and ID-theft recovery, on top of Complete's antivirus-backed browsing protection, monitoring, password manager and 1 TB storage. Proton's answer is Proton Unlimited, which adds Mail, Pass, Drive and Calendar rather than insurance products.

Can I pay monthly instead?

Yes on both. Proton lists VPN Plus at $9.99 a month month-to-month. NordVPN publishes a one-month term as well, at the highest rate on its page, and the one-year terms sit between the two extremes at EUR 5.49 and EUR 6.49 a month for the first year.

Spot an outdated price or feature? Let us know and we'll verify it.

Heraldware analysis engine

reviewed · data sourced from official product pages · sources: nordvpn.com, protonvpn.com